Can I just put it on record that

I HATE CACHING BY PHONE 

The battery life is rubbish (or at least my iphone is), they are fragile, not waterproof, accuracy isn't great, no clip to put on my belt loops.

Shall I go on 

I agree too!

But, if you look at the newest Garmin's, they basically are smartphones 

I am going to be controversial and say yes. But only because it is more a yes than a no.

I am not using an iAnything, I am using android. I do not use a Geocaching app by Groundspeak, I use non-official ones. The battery life is good. The accuracy is on par with my GPSr. The only time my GPSr comes out of my backpack now is when setting a cache to double check the coordinates, it has agreed with the phone each time so far. And I always carry the GPSr so that I have it available to include it in a photo for other location based games.

The only negatives I see at the moment is fragility and water tightness, but it feels much more rugged sat in the flip-open padded case.

Until I gave the phone a good try I was not convinced. Everywhere was telling me that a dedicated GPSr was the equipment to have. But my GPSr

Quote from: SangueG on September 30, 2013, 08:50:40 am

But my GPSr cannot scan gc.com and pick out a few caches to go and do whilst laying in bed

You go caching in your bed.  Impressive

I am going to be controversial and say yes. But only because it is more a yes than a no.

I am not using an iAnything, I am using android. I do not use a Geocaching app by Groundspeak, I use non-official ones. The battery life is good. The accuracy is on par with my GPSr. The only time my GPSr comes out of my backpack now is when setting a cache to double check the coordinates, it has agreed with the phone each time so far. And I always carry the GPSr so that I have it available to include it in a photo for other location based games.

The only negatives I see at the moment is fragility and water tightness, but it feels much more rugged sat in the flip-open padded case.

Until I gave the phone a good try I was not convinced. Everywhere was telling me that a dedicated GPSr was the equipment to have. But my GPSr cannot scan gc.com and pick out a few caches to go and do whilst laying in bed. I cannot use my GPSr to create a pocket query whilst sat almost anywhere, and I certainly cannot download the pocket query straight to it on the fly and have all the caches available to me immediately. I can with the phone. My GPSr can only store 500 waypoints, the phone has no limit to the amount it can store (not an easily measurable amount anyway). I can also log the caches on-line wherever I am... just a few of the good points.

I've used two smartphones which includes my current one and they have been OK in good signal areas but put in a more trickier area like: woods, in the base of a valley or in town and they struggled to the point I had to give up. And battery power, well that on both phones has been pants!

The one thing I think is brilliant, is the instant nature of a smartphone, being able to get caches while out but this costs and I can't afford it, so for me, a smartphone looses one of its major plus points.

This subject has many topics that can be discussed / debated. Nice one Griff Grof for bringing up

I'll pick one point made for the moment to explain how I use / get around, and that is this one brought up by walktall:

The one thing I think is brilliant, is the instant nature of a smartphone, being able to get caches while out but this costs and I can't afford it, so for me, a smartphone looses one of its major plus points.

I have a 250mb per month included with my basic phone plan. Since the beginning of the year when I got the phone I have not used more than 100mb per month, and so have not paid any extra. How I have got around this is two fold, but both by using the wifi. When I am out in places like Tesco's for example, I connect to their free wifi. For the times I am not in the range of such free wifi, because I have BT broadband I can tap into free wifi spots all over the country (and the world apparently), and so use this to check on new caches and check email notifications. The BT wifi hotspots are extensive and I have been surprised where I have picked up a signal, for example when I placed the Ciren Movable Cache in the farmland behind our house yesterday I was connected where I hid it which was over 500' from the nearest building.

When I plan to do a number of caches, which has not been often this year, I create and download a PQ straight to my phone so have everything stored on there like I would if I had created a PQ downloaded to my PC and transferred to my GPSr via a cable. I have done this whilst out and about, and whilst laying in bed ..I don't sleep well, I have to do something in bed, and yes there is probably more interesting I could be doing there

This subject has many topics that can be discussed / debated. Nice one Griff Grof for bringing up

I'll pick one point made for the moment to explain how I use / get around, and that is this one brought up by walktall:
I have a 250mb per month included with my basic phone plan. Since the beginning of the year when I got the phone I have not used more than 100mb per month, and so have not paid any extra. How I have got around this is two fold, but both by using the wifi. When I am out in places like Tesco's for example, I connect to their free wifi. For the times I am not in the range of such free wifi, because I have BT broadband I can tap into free wifi spots all over the country (and the world apparently), and so use this to check on new caches and check email notifications. The BT wifi hotspots are extensive and I have been surprised where I have picked up a signal, for example when I placed the Ciren Movable Cache in the farmland behind our house yesterday I was connected where I hid it which was over 500' from the nearest building.

My issue is £10 a month is toooo much, I can't justify that cost for something I would use effectively just for geocaching and the odd (very odd) need to make a phone call. It would also need to be Windows based mobile, as Memory Map on Android is no where near as good

I do make use of wifi hotspots, which is great. I remember being in Letterkenny logging a TB to make sure the history stayed correct, as I was on holiday for another six days after dropping off the TB

Personally I prefer a separate GPSr but since upgrading my smartphone I can now actually find caches with it! 

Going in the other direction, Garmin are about to launch an Android based GPS which has everything apart from a phone (but will connect to WiFi). Garmin Monterra. http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/122006-garmin-monterra-outdoor-gps-pictures-and-hands-on

It's even got a smartphone price!